crazypeter wrote:I use PT3 and a friend uses HM and he showed me a nice feature i really miss in PT3! It's called "Player Analysis", it's like a second window where all players you're currently playing with at the tables appear in a list and detailed information about everyone of them. For example information like "high check/fold as preflop raiser" or "Very high preflop 4-bet" etc. etc. and a really nice feature where you can see the range he already 3-betted with for example or his coldcalling range.
"High check/fold as preflop raiser"... according to who? This kind of information is highly questionable. For one, how did they determine what a "good" check/fold as preflop raiser value is? Do they take into consideration different playing styles? There are, after all, more than one winning style, and they don't all match up exactly in various aspects. Do they take the number of players at the table account? What might be a high value at a 10 player table might be extremely low at a heads up table. These are just a few questions that need answered. Like I said, this information is extremely questionable, and I would hesitate to place any confidence in it at all.
We may provide something like this in the future, but it's going to have to be reliable information. We're not going to simply accumulate a large number of hand histories, look for the winners, then average their stat values and say that's what a "good" value is. Unreliable or misleading information is often less valuable than no information at all.